Transparent Labs vs. 1st Phorm: Honest Comparison (Which Wins?)

We test and review fitness products on an independent, multi-point methodology. If you buy through our links we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. This is a formula-led brand comparison based on current labels.

Transparent Labs

Best for Disclosed Formulas & Natural Flavoring

Transparent Labs

Performance ecosystem

1st Phorm

Best for Built-In Creatine & Broader Nutrition

1st Phorm

The verdict, fast

Transparent Labs Clean, fully disclosed formulas with natural flavoring and broader disclosed dosing in the products compared here.

1st Phorm A broader ecosystem — built-in creatine, rapid-vs-sustained protein options, and a coaching/nutrition system.

Bottom line Transparent Labs is the better default for readers who prioritize disclosed formulas and dosing. 1st Phorm fits someone who wants built-in creatine, protein variety, or the broader brand system.

Expert Review

Nader Qudimat

20+ years lifting · 200+ products tested

These two brands sell different philosophies. Transparent Labs is built around fully disclosed labels, natural flavoring and performance-first dosing — no proprietary blends, no artificial sweeteners. 1st Phorm is a broader ecosystem: multiple protein types for different jobs, built-in creatine in its pre-workout, and a coaching/nutrition layer around the products.

For someone choosing on formula transparency and dosing, Transparent Labs is the cleaner pick. For someone who wants creatine already in the pre-workout, a fast-vs-sustained protein split, or the surrounding system, 1st Phorm makes more sense.

The matchups below are the ones that actually line up product-to-product. Where a 1st Phorm product hasn't been personally tested in its current formula, this stays a formula comparison rather than a firsthand verdict.

Formula comparison based on current labels. Where the exact current 1st Phorm product hasn't been personally tested, no firsthand Experience Profile is shown.

TL Whey

Phormula-1

Protein: TL Whey vs Phormula-1

Lean isolate

Rapid whey isolate

Type Grass-fed whey isolate

Type Rapid-assimilating whey isolate

Calories & macros Flavor-dependent

Sweeteners Natural (no artificial)

Sweeteners [PULL: current label]

Sizes 2LB & 4LB

Sizes [PULL: current sizes]

Flavors [PULL: TL flavor count]

Flavors [PULL: Phormula-1 flavor count]

Price / 25g protein [PULL: computed]

Best use General high-protein isolate

Best use Fast post-workout recovery

Lactose positioning Whey isolate; severe-intolerance warning

Lactose positioning Very small traces; not marketed as lactose-free

Don't call either universally better for muscle growth just because it digests faster — total protein, amino profile and training matter more. Both are whey isolates and contain milk; neither is guaranteed lactose-free, and exact calories, protein, servings and macros vary by flavor/variant — the values shown pull from the selected Product CPT variant, not one universal panel.

Protein: TL Whey vs Level-1

This isn't a direct isolate-vs-isolate comparison. TL Whey is a lean whey isolate; Level-1 is 1st Phorm's sustained-release protein intended more as a snack or meal replacement. 1st Phorm itself positions Phormula-1 as the faster recovery product and Level-1 as the sustained meal/snack option — so compare TL Whey to Phormula-1 for recovery, and treat Level-1 as a different category.

Bulk and Project-1 both run 200mg caffeine — the real split is Bulk's broader creatine-free daily formula vs Project-1's built-in 5g creatine.

Category winners

Transparent Labs Clean-label performance products

Transparent Labs Natural flavoring emphasis

1st Phorm Broader protein-use categories

1st Phorm Built-in creatine pre-workout

Transparent Labs Creatine-free daily pre-workout

1st Phorm Brand ecosystem / coaching

Transparent Labs Formula transparency

Transparent Labs Overall FitFrek recommendation

Who Should Choose Each Brand?

Choose Transparent Labs if

You prioritize fully disclosed formulas
You want natural flavoring, no artificial sweeteners
You want broader disclosed dosing in the products compared here
You take creatine separately
Clean-label matters more than a built-in system

Choose 1st Phorm if

You want creatine built into the pre-workout
You want fast-vs-sustained protein options
You follow the brand's nutrition/coaching system
You want a broader product ecosystem
A compact performance formula appeals to you

Where to Buy

Live pricing

Nutricartel

Ships US · Free over $60

Best Price

$64.99

Buy →

Prices updated today · Code FITFREK at most retailers

FAQ

Which brand is better overall? ▼

For clean, fully disclosed formulas and dosing, Transparent Labs. For built-in creatine, protein variety and the broader system, 1st Phorm.

Which protein has more per scoop? ▼

TL Whey and Phormula-1 report different protein per serving depending on the selected variant ([PULL: TL Whey protein/serv] vs [PULL: Phormula-1 protein/serv]). They're also built for slightly different jobs — lean isolate vs rapid recovery.

Which pre-workout has creatine? ▼

Project-1 includes 5g creatine. Bulk is creatine-free by design.

Which has more caffeine? ▼

Bulk and Project-1 both provide 200mg of caffeine per full serving.

Which is better value? ▼

Use the current dynamic prices and price-per-serving — it shifts with sales and subscriptions on both sides.

Bottom line

Transparent Labs is the better default for most FitFrek readers — disclosed formulas, natural flavoring and broader disclosed dosing in the products compared here.

1st Phorm makes more sense for someone who wants built-in creatine, a fast-vs-sustained protein split, or the broader nutrition and coaching system.

Related Transparent Labs Guides

💵

Tried Transparent Labs or 1st Phorm? Get paid.

Submit a verified review and earn a gift card.

Learn how→

Nader Qudimat

20+ years lifting · 200+ products tested

View full profile →

Transparent Labs 1st Phorm